What Do Magistrates Think About Character References?

Character references can have a genuine impact in magistrates’ court — but only if they’re done properly. They won’t make charges disappear, but they can influence how a person is viewed at sentencing or when deciding whether an offence was out of character.

Magistrates want to know who you are beyond the offence. A good reference might come from an employer, community figure, teacher, or family friend who knows you well and can vouch for your usual behaviour. The best references are honest, specific, and focused on your personal qualities — not just a plea for leniency.

That said, poorly written or generic references are likely to be ignored. If a letter simply says you’re a “nice person” or “would never do this”, without acknowledging the offence or showing insight, it may actually harm your case. Magistrates are looking for credibility, not flattery.

If you're preparing for sentencing, character references can be one part of your mitigation. So can things like early guilty pleas, remorse, and personal circumstances. Understanding what you can say to reduce your sentence and how to present yourself in court matters just as much.

It’s also worth reading about sentencing outcomes in magistrates court to get a realistic idea of what you’re facing. That way, your references can be used alongside a stronger strategy — not as your only hope.

Request a Case Review →