What Happens If You Plead Not Guilty in Magistrates’ Court?

If you plead not guilty in magistrates’ court, your case will not be resolved at the first hearing. Instead, the court will set a future trial date and begin a formal process that involves the prosecution providing evidence and you or your legal representative preparing your defence. This can be a stressful and confusing time, especially if you are unfamiliar with court procedures — which is why it helps to understand how to prepare for a trial in magistrates court.

At the first hearing, the magistrates will confirm your plea and may ask questions about the nature of your defence. They will then begin what is called case management, where both sides are expected to disclose the evidence and issues that will be raised at trial. You will also receive key deadlines, including when the prosecution must serve its evidence and when you must respond - which makes it essential to know what evidence to bring to magistrates court.

The court will decide whether the trial should be heard in the magistrates’ court or sent to the Crown Court. For many offences, this decision is based on the seriousness of the case and whether you or the magistrates choose to send it up. If it remains in the magistrates’ court, a new date will be set for trial and you will be expected to return with your defence ready.

You will usually need to provide a list of witnesses you want to call, along with any documents or evidence you plan to rely on. You might also be asked to confirm whether you are instructing a solicitor or representing yourself. If you are unrepresented, the court may take extra care to explain things, but the expectations remain the same.

The prosecution will present its case first at trial. You will then have the opportunity to question their witnesses and present your own evidence. After both sides have spoken, the magistrates or district judge will decide on a verdict. If you are found not guilty, you will be free to leave and the case ends there. If you are found not guilty, you will be free to leave and the case ends there. If you are found guilty, sentencing may happen immediately or at a later date — to get a clearer picture, it helps to understand what sentencing outcomes are possible in magistrates court.

Pleading not guilty is your right. But it also begins a structured legal process that demands preparation, organisation, and clear thinking. If you are unsure how your case might be viewed by the court, a pre-trial case review can help. Magistrate Review provides confidential, impartial analysis from a serving magistrate so you can walk into court informed and prepared.

Request a Case Review →