Can I Represent Myself in Magistrates’ Court and Win?

Many people facing criminal charges wonder whether they can represent themselves in magistrates’ court and still achieve a fair outcome. The answer is yes — you have the legal right to represent yourself, and many people do. But winning without legal representation depends heavily on your ability to prepare, understand the process, and know what to expect at your first hearing.

Magistrates and district judges are used to seeing unrepresented defendants. The court will do its best to explain what is happening, but it is not their job to help you argue your case. If you don’t understand the law, court procedure, or what evidence you should bring, you may be at a disadvantage — particularly if the prosecution is experienced and well prepared.

However, representing yourself does not automatically mean you will lose. If the case is straightforward, if you are organised, and if you understand your rights and responsibilities, you can still make a strong impression. Respectful behaviour, calm communication, and a clear and relevant explanation of your circumstances all count in your favour.

What many self-representing defendants lack is perspective. Without experience of how magistrates think, how evidence is weighed, and what questions matter, it’s easy to focus on the wrong points or say too much. That’s where preparation becomes critical. You can represent yourself, but you should not walk in unprepared — especially if you've decided to plead not guilty in magistrates’ court.

Magistrate Review provides impartial, structured case reviews written by a serving magistrate. We help you see your case through the eyes of the bench, so you know what to expect and how to focus your efforts. Whether or not you choose to represent yourself, we can help you feel informed and ready for court.

Request a Case Review →