Will the Court See My Side of the Story?

Many defendants worry that the magistrates won’t understand what really happened. When emotions are high, it’s natural to fear that your side of the story won’t come across clearly — especially if the prosecution paints a different picture. But the court’s job is to listen to both sides and weigh the evidence fairly.

Magistrates are trained to be impartial. They don’t automatically believe the police or assume guilt. Instead, they look at what is said, how it’s said, and whether it’s supported by any evidence. If you want your version of events to be heard and taken seriously, it needs to be presented calmly, clearly, and with relevant detail.

Your story can be just as persuasive as anyone else’s — but how you tell it matters. Emotional outbursts, contradictions, or vague statements will weaken your position. The key is preparation. If you’ve made common magistrates court mistakes in how you present yourself or your evidence, the court may struggle to understand your point of view.

One of the most effective ways to ensure the court hears you properly is to gather supporting documents, prepare your responses, and get an outside view. A structured case review can help you see whether your explanation holds weight — and how to deliver it in a way that magistrates are more likely to accept.

If you're still unsure what will actually happen on the day, reading about what to expect at your first hearing can also help ease your nerves and clarify the process.

Request a Case Review →